On September 23, 1957, The Three Faces of Eve opened in American movie theaters, starring newcomer Joanne Woodward as multiple personality-possessing Eve White. Based on a book by Corbett Thigpen and Hervey M. Cleckley, the movie related the story of real-life Chris Costner Sizemore, who revealed her identity as Eve in her 1977 book, I’m Eve.
Personality #1 Eve White is a mild-mannered housewife who suffers from blinding headaches and occasional blackouts. She consults psychiatrist Dr. Curtis Luther (Lee J. Cobb; On the Waterfront, Twelve Angry Men), who meets Personality #2, wild trouble-maker Eve Black, when he puts Eve #1 under hypnosis. Eve #2 knows about Eve #1, but unfortunately Eve #1 doesn’t know about Eve #2. Both Eves are institutionalized when Eve #2 tries to kill their daughter, Bonnie.
Dr. Luther continues to treat the Eves, and helps #1 to remember a deeply traumatic childhood event which led to her personality split (revealed in a spoiler review by Bosley Crowther of the New York Times). During this work, a stable Personality #3 emerges and takes the name of Jane. Jane is able to remember everything about Eve #1 and Eve #2, the Eves merge into Jane, and the happy ending sees Jane remarried and reunited with Bonnie.
Joanne Woodward won an Academy Award for Best Actress for her role(s) as Eve, Eve, and Jane. Two other actresses were rumored to be considered for the part: Judy Garland (director Nunally Johnson’s preference, but deemed too “unreliable”); and June Allyson (who let herself be talked out of it by husband Dick Powell, advising her she’d be “miscast”). Orson Welles was reportedly offered the role of Dr. Luther, but declined in order to direct Touch of Evil. David Wayne (How to Marry a Millionaire) appeared as Eve #1 & #2’s husband, Ralph; Nancy Kulp (The Bob Cummings Show, The Beverly Hillbillies) played the role of Mrs. Black; and Alistair Cooke (PBS’s Masterpiece Theater, America) warmed up his voiceover chops as the narrator, lending a British flavor of authenticity and reliability to the tale. Nunally Johnson both directed and wrote the screenplay for the Twentieth Century Fox production.